Public Defenders in the State Court

 View Only
Expand all | Collapse all

Request for feedback on proposed statutory change related to public defender CLE expenses

  • 1.  Request for feedback on proposed statutory change related to public defender CLE expenses

    Posted 07-21-2023 09:53

    Dear Nebraska Public Defender Community:

    The Nebraska State Bar Association recently discovered a discrepancy in the statutes between elected public defenders and contract public defenders as it related to covering expenses for continuing legal education. Anecdotally, we have heard of public defender offices that do not cover CLE expenses for their lawyers. Is this an issue for you or your office? We would appreciate your feedback as to whether this is a statutory change worth exploring.

    Contract Public Defenders

    Currently, Nebraska Rev. Statute. 23-3406 provides for the terms of public defender contracts. Among other things, the statute provides that the contract between the contracting attorney and the county board specify that the attorney shall receive at least ten hours of continuing legal education annually in the area of criminal law and that the contract between the contract attorney and the county board provide funds for the contracting attorney's required continuing legal education.

    "(6) The contract between the contracting attorney and the county board shall provide that the contracting attorney shall receive at least ten hours of continuing legal education annually in the area of criminal law. The contract between the county board and the contracting attorney shall provide funds for the continuing legal education of the contracting attorney in the area of criminal law."

    Elected Public Defenders

    Alternatively, Neb. Rev. Statute 23-3403 addresses support and compensation for elected public defenders. The statute does not currently address expenses related to continuing legal education expenses. 

    "The public defender may appoint as many assistant public defenders, who shall be attorneys licensed to practice law in this state, secretaries, law clerks, investigators, and other employees as are reasonably necessary to permit him or her to effectively and competently represent the clients of the office subject to the approval and consent of the county board which shall fix the compensation of all such persons as well as the budget for office space, furniture, furnishings, fixtures, supplies, law books, court costs, and brief-printing, investigative, expert, travel, and other miscellaneous expenses reasonably necessary to enable the public defender to effectively and competently represent the clients of the office."

     

    As you know, we have a number of public defender offices with vacancies right now. Data indicate that employer paid professional development can be an important tool for employee retention. In the NSBA's 2022 Economic Survey, paying expenses for CLE and professional development ranked #1 in terms of the top benefits provided by legal employers. It ranked #6 (out of 25) of benefits most important to lawyers if they were looking for a job.

     

    As such, we would like to solicit your feedback regarding a proposed revision to 23-3403:

    "The public defender may appoint as many assistant public defenders, who shall be attorneys licensed to practice law in this state, secretaries, law clerks, investigators, and other employees as are reasonably necessary to permit him or her to effectively and competently represent the clients of the office subject to the approval and consent of the county board which shall fix the compensation of all such persons as well as the budget for tuition, fees, and other expenses incurred to meet attorney continuing legal education requirements, office space, furniture, furnishings, fixtures, supplies, law books, court costs, and brief-printing, investigative, expert, travel, and other miscellaneous expenses reasonably necessary to enable the public defender to effectively and competently represent the clients of the office."

     

    Please send me your thoughts by August 1, 2023 via this listserv or directly to Lneeley@nebar.com. Thanks in advance for your consideration and feedback on whether this proposal is worth exploring.

     

    Sincerely,

     

    Liz Neeley

     

     

    Liz Neeley, Ph.D.

    Executive Director

    Nebraska State Bar Association

    lneeley@nebar.com

    635 S 14th St. #200 | Lincoln NE 68508

    (402) 742-8129

    facebook-32twitter-32linkedin-32

    NSBA Logo

     

     



  • 2.  RE: Request for feedback on proposed statutory change related to public defender CLE expenses

    Posted 07-21-2023 10:18

    Liz:

     

    I see that as a great benefit for PD offices throughout the state. Now that in person CLE are going to be required again, the expenses can add up for the many offices of Public Defenders. I would like to see this change made for the benefit of those offices.

     

    Bob Lindemeier






  • 3.  RE: Request for feedback on proposed statutory change related to public defender CLE expenses

    Posted 07-21-2023 15:05

    Dawson County also has a contract with this provision already included. 

     

    Sent from Mail for Windows

     






  • 4.  RE: Request for feedback on proposed statutory change related to public defender CLE expenses

    Posted 07-21-2023 12:20

    Dear Liz,

     

        This is not an issue in Hall County. There is a budget line item in the Hall County  Public Defender Budget for training.

     

                                                                                                                                    Gerry Piccolo

     






  • 5.  RE: Request for feedback on proposed statutory change related to public defender CLE expenses

    Posted 07-21-2023 12:25
    Thank you, Liz, but Washington County pays for mine.
    Thanks, Dunn






  • 6.  RE: Request for feedback on proposed statutory change related to public defender CLE expenses

    Posted 07-24-2023 07:35

    The Sarpy County Public Defender's Office has CLE's factored into our budget but if others do not...it is an important needed fix in the statute.

     

     

    Thomas P. Strigenz

    Sarpy County Public Defender

    1208 Golden Gate Drive, Suite 1700

    Papillion,  NE 68046

    (402) 593-5933

    tstrigenz@sarpy.com

     

     

     

     

     






  • 7.  RE: Request for feedback on proposed statutory change related to public defender CLE expenses

    Posted 07-21-2023 13:13
    Not an issue in Cedar County. I believe we have a $2,500 CLE reimbursement expense amount listed in our contract. 

    Sincerely,

    Nikki Brandt

    Kennedy Pier Loftus & Reynolds, LLP
    322 Walnut Street
    Yankton, SD 57078
    605-665-3000 p
    605-665-2670 f

    image001.png


    CONFIDENTIALITY: This reply is from the law firm of Kennedy Pier Loftus & Reynolds, LLP, and contains information which may be confidential and legally privileged. If you have received this message in error, you are strictly prohibited from reading it and from disclosing or using its contents in any manner, and you should immediately delete it. The unauthorized disclosure or use of confidential or privileged information inadvertently transmitted to you may result in criminal and/or civil liability.






  • 8.  RE: Request for feedback on proposed statutory change related to public defender CLE expenses

    Posted 07-21-2023 13:44

    The Lancaster County Public Defender's Office has CLE factored into our budget, along with travel/meals/publications/subscriptions/etc.. 

     

    Kristi Egger

    Lancaster County Public Defender

     

    Sent from Mail for Windows

     

    CONFIDENTIALITY NOTICE: This e-mail message, including any attachments, is for the sole use of the intended recipient(s) and may contain confidential and privileged information. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure or distribution is prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender by reply e-mail and destroy all copies of the original message.





  • 9.  RE: Request for feedback on proposed statutory change related to public defender CLE expenses

    Posted 07-21-2023 15:35
    Liz,

    I believe this is crucial language to assist those Public Defender offices that are currently responsible for their own CLE expenses.  Fortunately, Buffalo County pays for all our CLE expenses.

    Jeff Wirth
    Buffalo County Public Defender 





  • 10.  RE: Request for feedback on proposed statutory change related to public defender CLE expenses

    Posted 07-21-2023 16:13
    We have it part of the contract for Fillmore County. 

    Sent from my iPhone





  • 11.  RE: Request for feedback on proposed statutory change related to public defender CLE expenses

    Posted 07-21-2023 13:51

    Liz,

    Not an issue for me in Colfax county.  I have a reimbursement amount built into the contract.  Although since I have a private practice that also benefits I rarely seek reimbursement. 

     

    Have a great weekend.

     

     

    Jerod L. Trouba
    Attorney-at-Law
    TROUBA LAW OFFICES LLC.
    1464 27th Ave.
    Columbus, NE 68601
    (402) 564-3274
    fax: (402) 564-7055
    jtrouba@troubalaw.com
     

     

    WARNING/CAUTION: This e-mail and any files transmitted with it are strictly confidential and are intended solely for the use of the individual or entity to whom it is addressed. This communication may contain material protected by lawyer-client privilege. If you are not the intended recipient or the person responsible for delivering the e-mail to the intended recipient, be advised that you have received this e-mail in error and that any use, dissemination, forwarding, printing, or copying of this e-mail and any file attachments is strictly prohibited. If you have received this e-mail in error, please immediately notify us by a telephone call to (402) 564-3274 or by reply e-mail to the sender. You must destroy the original transmission and its contents.

     

     

     






  • 12.  RE: Request for feedback on proposed statutory change related to public defender CLE expenses

    Posted 07-21-2023 20:00
    Hi Liz,
    Sorry for drifting from the main topic, but it is Friday.  My practice is limited to an elected PD position, a contract PD position and court appointed criminal cases.  I agree with the discussion on PD's educational expenses and the need to be adequately compensated..  Given the complexities of today's criminal felony cases, particularly in regard to scientific-electronic-social media issues, I would also support an approved list of court appointed defense attorney system to be modeled after the GAL system, which would require a basic course to qualify for appointment and 4 hours CLE annually to stay qualified.  AND court appointed attorneys need adequate compensation. 

    --
    Rodney W. Smith
    Attorney at Law
    P.O. Box 590
    O'Neill, NE 68763
    Tel: 402-640-5436
    Fax:402-939-0595

    NSBA # 16046

    WARNING: The information contained in this electronic mail transmission is intended solely for its authorized recipient(s) and may contain CONFIDENTIAL AND PRIVILEGED information. If you are not an intended recipient, you are hereby notified that you are strictly prohibited from reading, copying, printing, distributing or disclosing any of the information contained in it. In that event, please contact us immediately by telephone (402-336-2847 ) or by electronic mail at the above address and delete the original and all copies of this transmission (including any attachments) without reading or saving in any manner.